Ipsy vs. Boxycharm: Which Subscription Box is Right for You?

Are you looking for a beauty subscription box that is perfect for your lifestyle and budget? If so, you’ve probably heard about Ipsy and Boxycharm and you might be wondering which one is right for you. Both of these popular subscription boxes offer their customers a variety of beauty products, from makeup to skincare and more. In this blog post, we’ll compare Ipsy and Boxycharm and provide you with all the information you need to decide which subscription box is best for you. Read on to find out more!

Ipsy Vs Boxycharm

Beauty lovers, if you’re on the hunt for some new pieces for your collection, or are looking to try out different products to up your makeup game, you’re in the right place.
In this Ipsy vs Boxycharm review, I’ll help you decide which brand is worth the subscription. First, let’s take a look at what each company is all about.

About Ipsy

Ipsy is a beauty subscription service that provides customers with a curated selection of makeup, skincare, and hair care products every month. Ipsy’s Glam Bag comes with 4-5 full-sized or deluxe-sample sized products each month tailored to a user’s beauty profile. This monthly subscription also includes a makeup bag and exclusive discounts on featured brands. Customers have the option to upgrade their Glam Bag to the Glam Bag Plus for an additional $25 a month which includes 6-7 full-sized products.
Ipsy’s mission is to create a “beauty utopia” where beauty lovers can find products that are unique, personalized and affordable. The brand offers an array of premium and cult-favorite brands, from Anastasia Beverly Hills to NARS Cosmetics, as well as up-and-coming and indie brands. Ipsy also offers tutorials, product recommendations and beauty news on its website and YouTube channel.

About Boxycharm

Boxycharm is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes on the market. It was founded by Joe Martin in 2013 with the mission of providing customers with full-size products at an affordable price. The box is renowned for its high-quality selection of items and has become a favorite among makeup aficionados and beauty influencers alike. Every month, subscribers receive 4-5 full-size beauty items that are hand-picked by experts to reflect the season’s trends. Boxycharm also offers subscribers a unique Charm Rewards system that allows them to purchase additional products at discounted prices. Subscriptions start at $25 per month and you can cancel your subscription at any time.

Ipsy Vs Boxycharm: Subscription Plans

Ipsy Glam Bag
The Ipsy Glam Bag is their basic monthly subscription plan. Each month you’ll get five beauty products personalized to your profile, along with a cute little makeup bag to store them in. The value of each bag is usually around $50, and you can expect to receive a mix of full-size and sample size products, mostly from indie brands but sometimes also from well-known names like Smashbox and Too Faced.
Ipsy Glam Bag Plus
For a few dollars more per month, you can upgrade to the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus. This plan gives you seven full-size items, including a combination of makeup, skincare, and haircare products, for a total value of about $125. Plus, you’ll get access to exclusive members-only discounts from top brands.
Boxycharm’s base subscription plan is their Charm Box, which sends five full-size beauty products for around $35 per month. Like Ipsy, you’ll receive a variety of makeup, skincare, and haircare items from both big-name brands and indie companies. You can also expect to get occasional tools and beauty accessories.
For an additional fee each month, you can upgrade to Boxycharm Premium. It’s the same as the Charm Box, but with seven full-size products instead of five. The price tag on this one is usually around $50 per month, but it has an estimated retail value of $175. Plus, you’ll get free shipping on all orders and access to exclusive perks.

Ipsy Glam Bag Vs Boxycharm Base Review:

The Boxycharm Base subscription includes four to five full-size products for the same price of $13/month. This box has a variety of beauty items, from makeup to skincare and haircare, so you’ll get an assortment of items from all across the beauty industry. The products are also chosen specifically for each subscriber, meaning they’ll always have a surprise waiting when they open their box.
When it comes to price point, both Ipsy Glam Bag and Boxycharm Base provide a great value, with 5 trial size products in the Glam Bag and 4-5 full size products in the Boxycharm Base subscription. However, there is a key difference between these two subscription boxes when it comes to selection and variety. The Ipsy Glam Bag focuses more on makeup and beauty products, while the Boxycharm Base offers a wide range of beauty products including makeup, skincare, haircare and nail care. Both subscriptions also offer unique benefits for subscribers, with Ipsy offering members access to exclusive discounts and product launches, and Boxycharm offering rewards points that can be used towards future purchases.
Ultimately, it will depend on your own personal preferences as to which box is best for you. If you are looking for a wide selection of beauty products from different categories, then Boxycharm Base may be the better choice. However, if you are more focused on makeup and beauty items, then the Ipsy Glam Bag may be better suited for your needs.

Ipsy Glam Bag Plus vs Boxycharm Premium Review:

When comparing the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus to the Boxycharm Premium box, it’s important to take into account both the price and the value. With the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus, you can receive up to five full-size products for $28/month, while the Boxycharm Premium box comes with six full-size products for $40/month. The contents of the Ipsy bag may be worth up to $120 while the Boxycharm box can be worth up to $215.
When it comes to customization, the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus offers three customizable products, while the Boxycharm Premium box allows customers to choose two of their six items. Ultimately, depending on your budget and preferences, either bag can offer great value for your money.

Ipsy Vs Boxycharm: What Do Customers Think?

Ipsy has been well-received by customers, who seem to appreciate the convenience of their pre-selected products. It has been lauded for its affordability and wide variety of products offered. Customers also praise the fact that each Glam Bag features a selection of sample sizes, allowing them to try out new products before committing to buying them. Additionally, Ipsy offers Glam Bag Plus subscribers an extra product in each month’s box and a variety of perks like free shipping.
On the other hand, Boxycharm seems to be slightly more hit or miss with customers. While many reviewers were happy with the quality and range of products included in the boxes, some complained about feeling disappointed by not receiving what was advertised. Similarly, shoppers have noted that the sample sizes in Boxycharm are often smaller than what is featured in Ipsy Glam Bags. Additionally, Boxycharm’s higher price tag and lack of perks such as free shipping has made some customers less inclined to purchase it.

Is Ipsy vs Boxycharm worth it?

When it comes to deciding whether or not to invest in a subscription service, the most important question is whether or not it is worth it. In the case of Ipsy vs Boxycharm, both subscription boxes offer unique advantages that could be worth the investment for different people.
Ipsy offers its subscribers a Glam Bag Plus and a Glam Bag Base. The Glam Bag Plus is their premium subscription that costs $25 per month and provides five full-size beauty products each month, along with personalized samples based on the customer’s beauty profile. The Glam Bag Base is the basic subscription that costs $12 per month and provides four deluxe-sized samples plus a bonus product or two.
Boxycharm also offers two different levels of subscription boxes. Their Base Box is the basic level and costs $21 per month and includes five full-size beauty products. The Premium Box is the top-tier subscription that costs $35 per month and offers six full-size items plus one additional item.
Both Ipsy and Boxycharm offer a wide variety of products including makeup, skincare, haircare, tools, accessories, and more. They also both provide opportunities to earn points and rewards when you review the products you receive.
Ultimately, the decision to subscribe to Ipsy or Boxycharm is up to you and your individual needs. If you are looking for affordable quality beauty products and personalized samples tailored to you, then Ipsy may be the right choice for you. However, if you’re willing to spend a bit more money and prefer the convenience of six full-size beauty items each month, then Boxycharm is the way to go. Either way, both companies provide excellent value for their customers and can be worth it for anyone who wants to stay on top of the latest beauty trends.


When it comes to choosing between Ipsy and Boxycharm, it ultimately comes down to your personal preference. Both services offer a great selection of products, excellent customer service, and a wide range of subscription plans. Ipsy offers more choice in terms of what products you receive each month while Boxycharm has more exclusive items. Ipsy also provides more makeup samples, whereas Boxycharm has larger sizes of full-sized products. Depending on your needs, either could be the right choice for you.
The best way to decide is to read reviews and compare subscription plans. Doing this will help you determine which service is the most affordable, has the most value, and best fits your needs. Ultimately, you want to choose the subscription box that you believe will make you happiest.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *